Q6 (16 Marks) Auxiliary Machinery
MEKG • Written Exam

With reference to mult-tubular heat exchangers explain:

(a) How and where impingement attack is likely to occur in the tubes

(b) Why is it desirable that coolant flow rate should not exceed that required to maintain correct fluid temperature

(c) Ample well-shaped water boxes and smooth tube inlets are desirable

(d) Partial obstruction of tube is a common cause of tube failure

Appeared In: Jan 2017

Verified Model Answer (Text Solution)

Structured for DG Shipping MEO Class II examination scoring criteria.

Exam Ready

(a) Impingement attack is a form of material degradation resulting from the erosive action of high-velocity fluid impacting a surface. The high-velocity fluid flow creates localised zones of high stress and turbulence, leading to material removal. The most susceptible locations for impingement attack are:

  • Tube bends: High-velocity flow changes direction, leading to material erosion.
  • Tube entrances: Sharp fluid acceleration causes localized erosion.
  • Heat exchanger shell in front of fluid entrance: Direct impingement of the incoming fluid can damage the shell.
  • Baffle plates: The deflection of fluid flow by baffles causes turbulence and erosion.
  • Openings like vents and drains: Concentrated flow in these areas increases erosion risk.
Part (b)

The rate of heat transfer in a heat exchanger is governed by the formula:

$$Q\:=\:\frac{A\:\times K\times\Delta T}{X}$$

Where,

  • Q is the heat transfer rate,
  • A is the area,
  • K is the heat transfer coefficient,
  • ΔT is the temperature difference, and
  • x is the tube thickness.
  • From the above equation, it is clear that the heat transfer is directly proportional to the mass flow rate.
  • If the flow rate is increased, the rate of heat transfer will increase.
  • But this will also increase turbulence and pressure drop which will lead to impingement corrosion.
  • Therefore it is desirable to keep the flow rate within limits to maintain the fluid temperature.
Part (c)

Ample well-shaped water boxes and smooth tube inlets are desirable because:

  • Well-shaped water boxes promote even flow distribution, reducing localized high-velocity zones that are conducive to impingement. Minimizing turbulence in the coolant minimizes the risk of erosion and corrosion.
  • Smooth tube inlets minimise flow disturbances at the tube entrance, reducing the impact force on the tube material and decreasing the likelihood of impingement damage. A smooth transition into the tube reduces the risk of localised erosion.
Part (d)

Partial obstruction of the tube is a common cause of tube failure:

  • Obstructions reduce heat transfer efficiency, leading to uneven thermal distribution (overheating or undercooling) and potential tube damage.
  • Deposits or obstructions increase frictional resistance, resulting in a pressure drop across the heat exchanger. This causes localized erosion, corrosion, and eventual tube failure.
← Back to MEKG Question Bank Upload Recent Question Paper →