Q8 (16 Marks) Propulsion & Shafting 🔥 Repeated 4x in exams
MEKG • Written Exam

(a) Explain why, despite accurate alignment under static conditions use of flexible couplings and copious supply of lubricant, main reduction gearing in still subject to pitting, scuffing and other tooth damage. (8)

(b) Discuss the significance of viscosity in relation to the function of marine turbine oils as used in main propulsion installations, stating how the viscosity is controlled and what could cause it to change in service. (8)

Appeared In: Jan 2025 - 1Jan 2024Apr 2023Dec 2025

Verified Model Answer (Text Solution)

Structured for DG Shipping MEO Class II examination scoring criteria.

Exam Ready
Part (a)

Why Gear Damage Occurs Despite Perfect Static Alignment & Lubrication

While perfect static alignment and abundant lubrication are essential starting points, they only represent a "baseline" condition. In operation, the dynamic environment of a marine propulsion system introduces severe forces and distortions that alter these ideal conditions.

1. Dynamic Misalignment and Structural Deflection

Static alignment is done in a cold, stable environment. Once the vessel is underway, several factors completely alter the geometry:

  • Hull Deflection: A ship's hull is flexible. Changes in cargo loading, ballast conditions, and rough sea states (hogging, sagging, and twisting) physically distort the engine room tank top and the gear casing foundation.
  • Thermal Expansion: As the turbine, gears, and bearings reach operating temperatures, they expand unevenly. This "thermal growth" shifts the shaft centerlines away from their cold, static alignment positions.
  • Torque Reaction: Under high power, the massive torque generated by the turbines causes the gear casing to twist slightly, concentrating loads on specific areas of the gear teeth.

2. EHD Lubrication Breakdown (Scuffing)

Even with a copious oil supply, the lubricant must form a continuous Elastohydrodynamic (EHD) film between the meshing teeth.

  • Scuffing occurs when this film momentarily ruptures due to localized high temperatures and extreme pressure.
  • Microscopic high points (asperities) on the tooth surfaces make direct metal-to-metal contact, instantly welding together and tearing apart as the gears rotate. This is usually triggered by sudden load increases or temporary overloads during maneuvering.

3. Cyclic Stress and Surface Fatigue (Pitting)

  • Pitting is a fatigue failure caused by repeated, cyclic contact stresses over millions of revolutions.
  • Even with flexible couplings absorbing major shocks, the gear teeth experience microscopic variations in load. Over time, sub-surface micro-cracks form.
  • High-pressure oil is forced into these tiny cracks during meshing, acting like a wedge and hydraulic jack that pops out small pieces of metal from the tooth surface, creating pits.

4. Limitations of Flexible Couplings

Flexible couplings (like membrane or dental/gear types) are designed to accommodate minor misalignment and axial float between the turbine and the pinions. However, they have limits.

  • They cannot isolate the main reduction gear from the axial thrust variations generated by the propeller or the heavy torsional vibrations inherent in the shafting system.
Part (b)

Viscosity in Marine Turbine Oils

Viscosity is the most critical property of a marine turbine oil, as it directly governs the oil's ability to support heavy loads while minimizing friction and heat generation.

Significance of Viscosity

  • Load-Bearing Capacity: The oil must have a high enough viscosity to maintain an unbroken hydrodynamic film in the journal bearings and an EHD film between the heavily loaded reduction gear teeth, preventing metal-to-metal contact.
  • Frictional Drag and Cooling: If the viscosity is too high, it increases internal fluid friction. This raises the operating temperature of the bearings, increases power losses, and makes it harder for the oil to flow rapidly to carry away heat.
  • System Balance: Marine propulsion systems often use a common lubrication system where the same oil lubricates both the high-speed turbine bearings (which require lower viscosity for cooling/speed) and the reduction gears (which require higher viscosity for load). The selected viscosity is a carefully engineered compromise, usually around an ISO VG 68 or 80 grade.

How Viscosity is Controlled in Service

Viscosity is primarily controlled by regulating the oil temperature, since viscosity drops as temperature rises and vice versa.

  • Thermostatic Control Valves: Automatic three-way valves (like wax-element or pneumatic valves) bypass or direct oil through the L.O. Coolers.
  • Target Temperature: The system is typically controlled to maintain the oil supply temperature to the bearings and gears within a strict range, usually between 40°C and 45°C, ensuring the oil hits its design viscosity at the point of application.

Causes of Viscosity Changes in Service

If the viscosity of the oil changes significantly during operation, it indicates contamination or chemical degradation:

1. Causes for a Decrease in Viscosity:

  • Fuel Oil Dilution: Unlikely in a pure steam turbine plant, but in gas turbine or diesel-geared configurations, fuel leaking into the lube oil system will rapidly thin the oil.
  • Shear Down: Permanent mechanical shearing of viscosity index (VI) improvers (if used) under the extreme squeezing forces between the gear teeth.

2. Causes for an Increase in Viscosity:

  • Oxidation: Prolonged exposure to high operating temperatures and oxygen causes the oil to break down chemically. This forms sludges, varnishes, and acidic byproducts that thicken the oil.
  • Insolubles and Carbon Contamination: The accumulation of micro-soot, wear debris, or atmospheric dust creates a suspension that increases fluid resistance.
  • Water Contamination (Emulsification): Gland steam leaks or leaking lube oil coolers introduce water into the oil. If violently agitated in the gears, it forms a thick "milky" emulsion, which temporarily alters the apparent viscosity and severely degrades load-carrying capability.
← Back to MEKG Question Bank Upload Recent Question Paper →