Q8 (16 Marks) Lubrication & Bearings 🔥 Repeated 3x in exams
MEKM • Written Exam

With respect to main boiler super heater arrangements:

(a) Compare the advantages and disadvantages of contra flow with parallel flow design.

(b) Describe how the element tube banks are supported yet allow for expansion

(c) Describe how boiler carryover affects super heater effectiveness and condition.

Appeared In: Jan 2023Jan 2020Apr 2018

Verified Model Answer (Text Solution)

Structured for DG Shipping MEO Class II examination scoring criteria.

Exam Ready
Part (a)

advantages and disadvantages of contra flow with parallel flow design.

Contra-flow

Parallel-flow

Steam and hot gases flow in opposite directions

Steam and hot gases flow in the same direction

Higher efficiency - larger temperature gradient

Lower efficiency - reduced temperature difference

Higher achievable superheat temperature

Limited maximum temperature

Higher differential may cause thermal stress

Lower differential = reduced stress

More responsive to gas temperature changes

Smoother but less responsive

Greater, especially near steam outlet

Lower risk, better temperature matching

Part (b)

Superheater Element Design for Thermal Expansion

Superheater elements, typically U-tubes or serpentine tubes, operate under high temperatures and undergo significant thermal expansion. Their design carefully accommodates this expansion while maintaining secure support:

  • Fixed at One End: The tubes are rigidly connected and securely anchored at either the header or the steam distribution manifold.
  • Free to Expand at Other End: The opposing end of the tube bank is engineered to move freely. This is achieved through sliding mechanisms within guides or by incorporating expansion loops, which absorb the thermal growth without inducing stress.
  • Hanger and Support Bars: The tubes are supported by hanging rods, beams, or alloy bars suspended from the boiler roof or steam drum. These supports are designed with inherent flexibility to accommodate slight movements.
  • Serrated or Slotted Tube Support Plates: These specialized plates provide lateral support for the tubes while featuring slots or serrations that permit longitudinal expansion. This design prevents binding and stress on the tubes.
  • Flexible Support Grids: Some boiler designs incorporate support grids made from heat-resistant alloys. These grids offer both stability for the tubes and the necessary freedom for them to expand under thermal load.

Part (c)

Boiler Carryover and its Effects

Boiler carryover refers to the undesirable entrainment of water droplets or impurities within the steam as it exits the steam drum. This phenomenon often results from issues like foaming, priming, or inherent deficiencies in drum design.

The effects of boiler carryover on the superheater and subsequent components are significant:

  • Heat Transfer Reduction: Water droplets in the steam lower the temperature of the incoming steam, which directly reduces the superheater's effectiveness. The absorption of latent heat by this moisture prevents the steam from reaching the desired superheat temperature.
  • Thermal Stress and Fatigue: The superheater tubes are subjected to fluctuating metal temperatures due to repeated exposure to alternating wet and dry steam. This leads to thermal cycling, which can cause fatigue cracking in the tube material.
  • Tube Scaling and Fouling: Impurities present in the carryover (such as salts or silica) deposit on the internal surfaces of the superheater tubes. These deposits act as insulation, leading to localized overheating, further reducing heat transfer efficiency, and creating potential hot spots that can damage the tubes.
  • Corrosion and Tube Damage: The presence of moisture and dissolved oxygen within the carryover promotes internal oxidation, pitting, and corrosion under deposit inside the superheater tubes. This significantly increases the risk of tube failure.
  • Turbine Blade Damage Risk: Ineffective superheating due to carryover means that wet steam may reach the turbines. This can cause erosion and significant damage to the turbine blades, impacting the overall efficiency and longevity of the turbine.
← Back to MEKM Question Bank Upload Recent Question Paper →