Q4 (16 Marks) Engine Operation & Maintenance 🔥 Repeated 2x in exams
MEP • Written Exam

(a) Discuss the Merits and demerits of a condition monitoring system compared to other maintenance regimes. (8)

(b) Describe how the data is gathered, stored and evaluated on a computer-based vibration analysis system. (8)

Appeared In: Nov 2024Sep 2022

Verified Model Answer (Text Solution)

Structured for DG Shipping MEO Class II examination scoring criteria.

Exam Ready
Part (a)

MERITS AND DEMERITS OF CONDITION MONITORING VS OTHER MAINTENANCE REGIMES

Merits of condition monitoring (CM):

  • Maintenance is based on actual condition, so components are serviced just before failure, avoiding both unnecessary overhaul and unexpected breakdown.
  • Early warning of developing faults, reducing the risk of catastrophic failure and consequential damage.
  • Extends machinery life and reduces downtime and maintenance cost.
  • Improves safety and reliability.
  • Allows maintenance to be planned at convenient times (e.g. in port).
  • Optimises spare-part usage and reduces inventory.
  • Provides a record/ trend of machinery condition for survey and management.

Demerits of CM:

  • Requires investment in monitoring equipment (vibration analysers, sensors, software) and training.
  • Requires skilled personnel to interpret the data correctly.
  • A fault may develop rapidly between monitoring intervals and be missed.
  • The monitoring system itself requires maintenance and calibration.
  • Initial set-up (baselines, measuring points) is time-consuming.
  • May not detect all fault types (e.g. sudden failures).

Comparison with other regimes:

  • Breakdown (reactive) maintenance: cheaper to set up but risks unexpected failure, downtime and damage; CM avoids this.
  • Planned/ preventive (time-based) maintenance: services components at fixed intervals regardless of condition, so components may be overhauled unnecessarily (waste) or fail before the interval; CM is more efficient but requires more data/ skill.
  • CM is a predictive/ condition-based approach that combines the reliability of preventive maintenance with the efficiency of only servicing what needs it.
Part (b)

HOW DATA IS GATHERED, STORED AND EVALUATED ON A COMPUTER-BASED VIBRATION ANALYSIS SYSTEM

  • Gathering: Vibration data is collected using accelerometers/ vibration transducers mounted at designated measuring points (bearing housings, machine feet). Data is collected either by a portable data collector/ analyser (taken to each point) or by permanently installed sensors feeding a monitoring system. The data includes overall vibration level and the vibration spectrum (frequency content).
  • Storage: The collected data is stored in a computer-based system (a vibration database/ software), organised by machine, measuring point, and date. Baseline (reference) spectra and historical trends are stored for each point.
  • Evaluation: The software analyses the data by:
  • Comparing the overall vibration level with alarm/ limit values (ISO/ classified standards).
  • Performing frequency analysis (FFT) to identify the frequency components and relate them to specific faults (e.g. unbalance at 1x rpm, misalignment at 1x/2x rpm, bearing faults at high frequencies, gear faults at gear-mesh frequency).
  • Trending the vibration levels and specific frequency components over time to detect the onset and rate of deterioration.
  • Comparing the current spectrum with the baseline to identify new/ growing components.
  • Generating reports/ alarms to alert the engineer to developing faults, so maintenance can be planned.
← Back to MEP Question Bank Upload Recent Question Paper →