Q6 (16 Marks) Lubrication & Bearings
MEP • Written Exam

(a) Outline the problems associated with effective lubrication of the liner and piston assembly of a large slow speed engine

(b) Describe the appearance and state the causes of EACH of the following

(i) Clover leafing

(ii) Micro seizure

(c) Describe the composition of a cylinder oil suitable for an engine operating on residual fuel.

Appeared In: Jan 2021

Verified Model Answer (Text Solution)

Structured for DG Shipping MEO Class II examination scoring criteria.

Exam Ready
Part (a)

The primary purpose of lubrication is to prevent metal-to-metal contact between the liner and piston rings by forming an oil film. However, maintaining effective lubrication in a large slow-speed engine is challenging due to the following factors:

  • The piston speed varies throughout the cycle. At Top Dead Center (TDC), the piston speed is zero, making it difficult to maintain an effective oil film.
  • High temperatures at TDC, where combustion occurs, lead to oil film breakdown.
  • Residual fuel oils often contain impurities such as ash, sediments, and catalytic fines, which can break the oil film and cause abrasive wear.
  • Sulfur in the fuel forms sulfur oxides during combustion, which react with moisture to form sulfuric acid, leading to corrosive wear.
  • High thermal and mechanical stresses inside the cylinder make it difficult for the lubricant to maintain its properties.
  • Ash and other deposits absorb lubricant, leading to unlubricated metal-to-metal contact, further breaking the oil film.
  • Ensuring optimal distribution of lubricating oil to all areas of the liner and piston assembly is difficult, especially at high loads or under uneven conditions.
Part (b)

(i) Cloverleafing:

Cloverleafing presents as corrosive wear on the cylinder liner surface, specifically around the lubricating oil quills. The wear pattern is characteristically shaped like a cloverleaf.

Causes of cloverleafing:

  • It stems from the formation of sulfuric acid
  • Sulfur in the residual fuel reacts with oxygen to form sulfur oxides during combustion.
  • These sulfur oxides combine with moisture or condensate to form sulfuric acid, which corrodes the liner surface.
  • The lower part of the liner, where jacket cooling water temperature is relatively low, is more prone to this type of corrosion, especially near the oil quills.

(ii) Micro-Seizure:

Micro-seizure looks like abrasive wear, with characteristic axial marks on the liner surface.

Causes of Micro-seizure:

  • Caused by localized contact between the liner and piston rings due to lubrication failure.
  • The breakdown of the oil film results in localized heat generation and micro-welding between the liner and piston rings.
  • As the piston moves, these welded areas tear, leaving behind characteristic axial marks on the liner surface.
Part (c)

Composition of cylinder oil suitable for an engine operating on residual fuel:

  • The oil should have a viscosity that enables the formation of an effective oil film but doesn't impede flow. SAE 50 is a common choice, with a viscosity typically between 16.3 mm²/s and 21.9 mm²/s at 100°C.
  • A high VI is essential, as it minimizes viscosity changes with temperature fluctuations, maintaining effective lubrication throughout the engine's operating range. A VI above 100 is generally desirable.
  • The TBN should be high enough to neutralize the acidic combustion byproducts from the sulfur in the fuel. A TBN of around 70 is often specified for engines using high-sulfur fuels; however, this will depend on the specific sulfur content of the fuel.
  • The oil must have low volatility to prevent ignition during operation.
  • The oil needs good detergency to keep the liner surface clean, preventing piston ring sticking and minimizing abrasive wear.
← Back to MEP Question Bank Upload Recent Question Paper →