Q4 (10 Marks) Electrical Circuits & Calculations 🔥 Repeated 6x in exams
MET • Written Exam

With reference to a three-phase shipboard electrical distribution system:

(a) Enumerate the advantages of an insulated neutral system. (4)

(b) Enumerate the disadvantages of an insulated neutral system. (4)

(c) Describe how the Earthed neutral system is Earthed. (4)

(d) Compare the use of an insulated neutral system as opposed to the use of an earthed neutral system with regards to the risk of electric shock from either system (4)

Appeared In: Jun 2026Mar 2026Sep 2025Dec 2024Mar 2024Feb 2024

Verified Model Answer (Text Solution)

Structured for DG Shipping MEO Class II examination scoring criteria.

Exam Ready
Part (a)

Advantages of an insulated neutral system:

  • In the event of a single earth fault, no earth fault current flows through the ship's hull due to the insulated neutral, minimizing fire hazards.
  • The hull does not carry current, ensuring safety from electrical currents passing through the structure.
  • A single earth fault does not cause generator breaker tripping, avoiding sudden blackouts or operational disruptions.
  • Harmonic currents caused by third harmonics in the generated voltage are prevented from flowing through the neutral, protecting the generator windings from overloading.
Part (b)

Disadvantages of an insulated neutral system:

  1. Only one system voltage (line-to-line) is possible, unlike earthed neutral systems which also provide line-to-neutral voltages.
  2. While an earth fault alarm and phase indicator are triggered, locating the exact fault location requires a time-consuming trial-and-error process.
  3. In cases of inductive or capacitive faults to earth, surge voltage can rise 3.5 to 4 times the system voltage, risking insulation failure and system collapse.
Part (c)

How the earthed neutral system is earthed:

A metallic resistor is inserted between the neutral point and the ship’s hull to limit earth fault current.

The resistor’s value is determined by:

$$R=\frac{V}{\sqrt3I}\:$$

Where,

  • V = Line voltage,
  • I = Full load current.

Metallic resistors are used for their stability, low maintenance, and ability to prevent arcing grounds.

Part (d)

Comparison of Shock Risk:

The risk of electric shock is considered equally dangerous in both earthed and insulated neutral systems. In an insulated system, normal leakage currents from capacitance and surface leakage, along with the possibility of earth faults, mean that touching live parts still carries a considerable shock risk. Similarly, in an earthed system, line-to-neutral voltages (even those as low as 110 or 250 volts) can be lethal under certain shipboard conditions, making neither system inherently safer regarding electric shock than the other. Appropriate safety precautions are essential for both systems.

← Back to MET Question Bank Upload Recent Question Paper →