Q7 (10 Marks) Electrical Circuits & Calculations
MET • Written Exam

(a) Describe the normal criteria used for setting thermal protection relays and its advantage compared to magnetic types. (6)

(b) The low-voltage release of an a.c. motor-starter consists of a solenoid into which an iron plunger is drawn against a spring. The resistance of the solenoid is 35Ω. When connected to a 220V, 50Hz, a.c. supply the current taken is at first 2A, and when the plunger is drawn into the "full-in" position the current falls to 0.7A. Calculate the inductance of the solenoid for both positions of the plunger, and the maximum value of flux-linkages in weber-turns for the "full-in" position of the plunger.

Appeared In: Jul 2018

Verified Model Answer (Text Solution)

Structured for DG Shipping MEO Class II examination scoring criteria.

Exam Ready
Part (a)

Thermal protection relays

are designed for sustained overcurrent protection, typically set between 105-120% of the full load current with a time delay. They are not intended for momentary overcurrents.

The overcurrent setting depends on the following:

  • The electrical system's maximum continuous load capacity determines the relay settings to ensure the system operates without tripping under normal conditions.
  • The relay settings are influenced by the insulation class and its capacity to withstand elevated temperatures.
  • The amount of power consumption and heat generated during normal operation is evaluated to set the relay accurately.
  • The relay takes into account the cooling mechanism in place to ensure that heat dissipation during operation is factored into the thermal protection settings.

Advantages of Thermal relays over Magnetic relays:

  • Thermal relays provide a time delay, preventing tripping from momentary overcurrents that might not cause actual damage. Magnetic relays respond much faster.
  • Thermal relays operate based on the heat generated by an overcurrent, offering a more accurate reflection of the actual thermal stress on the system. Magnetic relays respond to the magnitude of the current, irrespective of heat generation.
  • Thermal relays are more economical because they use bimetals instead of more expensive magnetic solenoid coils.
  • Thermal relays are effective for sustained overcurrents, providing protection that is independent of other factors like the system voltage or magnetic field fluctuations.
Part (b)

Given:

$$Resistance \space of \space solenoid \space = \space 35Ω$$

$$Supply \space voltage \space = 220V, \space 50Hz$$

$$Initial \space current \space = \space 2A$$

$$Current \space in \space "Full-in" \space position \space = \space 0.7A$$

When plunger is out (initial stage),

$$Impedance \space (Z) \space = \space {{220} \over 2} \space = \space 110Ω$$

$$Inductive \space reactance \space (X) \space = \space \sqrt{Z^2 - R^2}$$

$$X \space = \space \sqrt{110^2 - 35^2} \space = \space 104.28Ω$$

$$Also, \space X \space = \space 2 \pi fl$$

$$l \space = \space {{X} \over 2 \pi f} \space = \space {{104.28} \over 2 \times 3.14 \times 50} $$

$$l \space = \space 0.33H$$

Inductance of solenoid when plunger is out = 0.33H

When "Full-in",

$$Impedance \space = \space {{V} \over I} \space = \space {{220}\over 0.7} \space = \space 314.286Ω$$

$$∴ \space X \space = \space \sqrt{314.286^2 - 35^2} \space = \space 312.33Ω$$

$$l \space = \space {{312.33} \over 2 \times 3.14 \times 50 } \space = \space 0.994H $$

$$Also, L \space = \space {{N \phi} \over I_{peak}}$$

$$∴ \space N \phi \space = \space L \space I_{peak}$$

$$∴ \space N \phi \space = \space 0.994 \times \sqrt{2} \times 0.7$$

$$∴ \space N \phi \space = \space 0.984 \space weber-turn$$

← Back to MET Question Bank Upload Recent Question Paper →